Today feels somber. For the first time in weeks, it’s gray and rainy outside. On top of that, this day marks the two-year anniversary of Hamas’s horrific terrorist attack on Israel. And finally – now that much of the dust has settled – I think it’s time to talk about the tragedy of Charlie Kirk’s assassination at more length. Not to sound cliche, but it does feel like a significant enough “turning point” to warrant much deeper reflection than our church has provided so far.
Of course, our church hasn’t ignored the subject entirely. We prayed more than usual the Sunday morning after it happened. And though we may not have gotten into as many specifics as some would have liked, with all due respect, you had to have been living under a rock to not recognize what we were talking about.
That said, part of the reason I’ve waited to speak more directly on the subject was to let cooler heads prevail from a situation that elicited such (understandable) shock, anger, and sorrow. In our social media age, we’re told that we must assume firm positions and issue bold statements as quickly as possible, rather than take time to pray and reflect (which is why so many rushed to condemn Charlie Kirk as a monster, or canonize him as a Martyr). That kind of environment is not exactly conducive to speaking with the sort of wisdom and care that addressing an event like this requires.
And finally, to be totally honest: I wasn’t all that familiar with Charlie Kirk before this happened. I knew who he was, but had never watched any of his videos or listened to his podcasts. I knew he was a conservative influencer and gifted debater who had a flare for being provocative. But beyond that, I simply wasn’t a Charlie Kirk lover or hater before his murder.
Now – with all of those disclaimers in mind about why we didn’t say more sooner – here’s some of what I’m currently thinking about all of this, along with a few suggestions about how believers at our church might think about it as well.
- We’ll start with the easiest one: Charlie Kirk was a fellow bearer of God’s image. He wasn’t some nameless, faceless ideological ally or opponent. He was a human being with God-given dignity and purpose. He was a husband, father, and neighbor. Those truths alone – the things we tend to forget about other people when we reduce them to labels, assign them to sides, and never actually meet them face to face – give us plenty of reason to grieve the violence that he, his family, and his friends have suffered.
- Next: Charlie Kirk was a brother in Christ. Generally speaking – unless we have some unique, personal, inside knowledge of someone’s life that raises legitimate questions about their faith in Jesus or the presence of the Holy Spirit in them – we should give people the benefit of the doubt when they profess their belief in the gospel. That may be even more true when someone shares their faith as regularly and publicly as Charlie Kirk did (which is a healthy challenge for all of us). It takes guts to speak as openly about Jesus as Charlie Kirk did on college campuses in our day, which suggests that his faith was more than a gimmick.
- Third: the crime committed against Charlie Kirk was evil. However wrong, rude, or even dangerous you think another person’s words, opinions, or stances are, it is evil to assume that you have some vigilante authority to violently end their life because of them (or act like a kid in a candy store when someone else does). As a result, the man who assassinated Charlie Kirk deserves whatever judgment is laid upon him (including the death penalty). Whatever his fate, Christians should pray that the assassin recognizes his actions for what they are – sin – and repents of it (if God’s power allows Erika Kirk to show her husband’s killer such grace, then we have no excuse).
- Fourth: I personally agree with – and our church formally affirms – much of the substance of what Charlie Kirk said about the transgender movement. For example – since all the way back in 2015, and to this day – our church’s bylaws have clearly stated our conviction that the only Biblically permissible context for sexual activity is between a biological male and biological female who are married to one another. I’ve preached on the transgender movement more pointedly several times before (in sermons from August of 2018 and April of 2024, if you’d like to hear them on this website). I specifically cite the transgender movement because Christian criticism of it – which appears to have been the primary force that drove Charlie Kirk’s assassin to murder – has been shared from PVCC’s pulpit and undergirds some of PVCC’s established practices. I hope and pray that our desire for fidelity to Scripture – and our insistence that the transgender movement is not the path to glorifying God or promoting human flourishing – doesn’t get someone gunned down on our stage some Sunday morning.
- Fifth: one can affirm the substance of some of Charlie Kirk’s words but question the tone. Whatever his reasons – whether noble or cynical – Charlie Kirk intentionally stirred the pot with his statements. In some situations, that sort of tone is necessary, good, and forces people to reflect on the substance (just read the minor prophets, or some of Jesus’s words to the religious leaders). In other situations, that tone can be unnecessarily offensive, counterproductive, and turn people away from the substance (when a person makes their living by saying things that people aren’t “supposed” to say, or refusing to bend the knee to “political correctness,” they’ll inevitably be tempted to say things in an overly brash or harsh manner). I say this to suggest that someone who questions some of Charlie Kirk’s less flattering speech – and as a result, doesn’t honor his legacy quite as enthusiastically as you do – isn’t our enemy.
There’s SO much more that could be said. However, I hope these words are helpful (though I’m sure I’ve stirred the pot myself with some of them). But in the spirit of Charlie Kirk: if you have further questions (or even deep disagreements) with what I’ve said or haven’t said here, or what our church has or hasn’t done in response to this event, let’s TALK about it.
And, of course – though it should go without saying – pray. Pray for those close to Charlie Kirk. Though this event may not be dominating the news the way it was a few weeks ago, their mourning is far from done (and in a sense, never truly will be). Additionally, pray for our nation. Perhaps this event will wake us up from the kind of moral and spiritual slumber that produces something as terrible as this. On top of that, pray for Christ’s church. Satan will use anything and everything to divide believers in Jesus (including – but not limited to – politics and current events). Pray that Christians speak wisely, carefully, and honestly about difficult subjects that must be addressed. That is especially challenging in a social media age that incentivizes and exacerbates fast and foolish speech. And finally, pray that if we learn nothing else from Charlie Kirk, we will learn to proclaim our faith in Christ unashamedly. The worst thing that Charlie Kirk’s assassin could accomplish is to silence more than just one believer with a single bullet.